In order to somehow connect the existence of closed time-like trajectories with temporal paradoxes, scientists at different times either proposed to introduce additional restrictive principles of a fundamental nature, or clarified the conditions under which these trajectories can exist.
List the most well-known of these restrictions.
1) Time travel is possible only on a submicroscopic scale.
In 1992, Stephen Hawking proposed to limit the scale on which time travel is possible. He formulated the chronological security hypothesis, which assumes that closed time-like curves can exist only on a submicroscopic scale. In this case, scale constraints can work in the opposite sense: for example, a rotating Tipler cylinder – one of the solutions of Einstein’s equations that allow closed time-like curves – must, on the contrary, have infinite length. Without the introduction of negative energy for Tipler cylinders of any finite length, no rotation is sufficient for the appearance of time-like closed curves.
Part of the limitations on scale are supported, for example, by string theory, which is considered one of the candidates for the place of universal theory of quantum gravity.
2) Any closed time-like curve passes through the event horizon, which makes the violation of the principle of causality invisible to the observer.
This principle, formulated in 1969 as the “space censorship hypothesis,” was formulated by Nobel Laureate in Physics 2020 Roger Penrose to somehow solve the problem of the existence of gravitational singularities. The principle states that singularities exist only in those areas of space-time that are inaccessible to the external observer (for example, beyond the event horizon of a black hole). Only in these areas of space-time invisible from the outside, according to the hypothesis, should all closed time-like curves appear. That is, if time travel is possible, no one will be able to see them.
It is worth saying, of course, that the validity of this principle is constantly questioned by scientists. Theoretical physicists have repeatedly tried to show that this hypothesis must be violated, but then reaffirmed the original postulate. One recent example is the work of William East last year, who refuted previous doubts and showed that all singularities and time-like curves are indeed below the event horizon.
3) Time travel is possible, but only if they do not violate the principle of causality
The principle of self-consistency was formulated by Igor Novikov in 1991. According to the hypothesis, closed time-like curves may exist in principle, but they link globally “self-consistent” events. Then the actions of the time traveler can only lead to local changes, and the probability of an action that changes an earlier event on the same curve is virtually zero. An illustration of this principle can be, in a sense, the plot of the film “12 monkeys”, in which any attempts by the hero Bruce Willis to change the past do not lead to anything.
Despite the fact that all these principles make it possible to resolve the contradictions that arise in some way, all of them, in general, remain rather postulates. Their theoretical basis still raises many questions and remains controversial. Some physicists believe that the problem of closed time-like curves will be solved by the theory of quantum gravity, in which, for example, there may be some fundamental prohibitions on their existence, and not just the conditions of their occurrence or observation.
